For the first time, Pride St. Louis decided to put the Trans community front and center in the parade in honor of Stonewall 50. Going a major step further, they attempted to ignite a discussion about Trans issues by asking police marchers to wear civilian clothing for this year’s celebration. Another idea was for unarmed officers to march in MTUG shirts. While many like myself enjoy seeing uniformed police in the parade as a symbol of how far we’ve come, other communities have very different realities. There are many marginalized people who don’t call the police when they need help. This was an opportunity to discuss that.
It didn’t go well.
Most in opposition genuinely felt this proposal was discriminatory and disrespectful to LGBTQ officers. They kept to those general talking points, and a few even offered a kind word to Trans friends and their supporters. Many others, however, poured gasoline on the controversy with hyperbolic, defamatory and discriminatory statements about both the Pride St. Louis Board as a whole, individual members–many who were sent hateful messages, and the Trans community.
I’ve been saying for over a week that proposals are often scrapped (remember the $5 entry fee?) as details are finalized, and today the Board has reversed the request after winning a concession from STLPD to attend diversity training.
Below is MTUG’s official statement:
This year, 50 years after the Stonewall riot, we were cautiously optimistic that we would finally be seen by our own community. Earlier this year, the board of Pride St Louis decided to center gender expansive and trans lived experiences by holding us up as grand marshals in honor of 50 years into our movement. When we agreed to take our place as grand marshals, we agreed to make our bodies vulnerable; we put our most marginalized community members at risk once again, especially our siblings of color. While hesitant, we agreed despite knowing that uniformed, armed police officers who have historically and presently criminalized our bodies would be in the parade. We have strained at best, and violent at worst, relationships with police officers. There has been no indication or effort made to gain an understanding or awareness by the police of who we are and what our community needs from our police officers. We knew that our constituency would be resistant to marching with armed officers however we wanted to work with the Pride Board and Parade team. Once the decision was made to exclude armed, uniformed police officers we finally felt seen, heard, understood and centered. Watching the backlash from white, cisgender gay and lesbian and straight community members, we realize that there is so much more work to be done. More than 50 years into this fight, we are not safe even within our own movement. So what are we going to do now? We don’t know. For right now, our leadership core is at a loss for words. We are disappointed. We are frightened. And, now quite frankly, we are much more aware of the massive targets on our backs put there by the Federal government, our state legislature, and our own community leaders.
An irony in all this is many of MTUG’s natural allies sat on their hands due to their general opposition to Pride St. Louis, ceding the field entirely to those opposed to the proposal. That of course was not helpful, but will be self-serving for the masturbatory cynics who can now say “I told you so.”
Pride is a community organization that answers to the community. They held firm longer than I could have expected, and hopefully the concession they won has some impact on the lives of people in our community. I commend their efforts.
I believe in the long run some good will come from this, mainly a better understanding of Trans issues. But for now, calls for unity will ring hollow after refusing to even listen to one another. We all limp towards Stonewall 50 battered and bruised.
And for those who have been drunk on rage, you’re going to have a hangover from Hell.
4 Replies to “Pride STL’s Police Uniform Decision Reversed. Trans Leaders Devastated.”
“There has been no indication or effort made to gain an understanding or awareness by the police of who we are and what our community needs from our police officers. ”
And as long as it’s an US or THEM situation… there never will be. This opportunity, marching side by side on this day, should be taken to heal that divide instead of taking offence and punctuating it.
It is on the police to take this opportunity to listen to the most marginalized people in the LGBQTIA community and NOT march in the parade. It is not on trans people, the people being oppressed by the police and the system they represent and uphold, to make concessions. Stop asking the folks with the least representation and power to once again have their concerns put aside for the “greater good”. The only way to heal the divide is for police to stop brutalizing citizens that they are supposed to be protecting, not for the brutalized to pretend that everything is ok for a day. No one is free until we are all free.
As a transgender woman, I do not feel welcome in any community around me other than the transgender community (and that is subject to the whims of even some transgender folks)
Even knowing that there are officers on the force who are against me, even having gone through a situation that I think was biased against me because of my transgender status, I am more comfortable around the police than not. Education is needed, for sure, diversity and sensitivity training, human rights and civil rights, all are needed, and not just for the first responders of our communities.
We all need to come together and learn to live and let live, not live and let die.
Very simply. I feel justified in saying that this was and is and never was a trans issue. It was a simple issue to recognize our total differences and diversity and welcome All into Celebrate the LBQTCisBinaryNon-conformed Communites In Pride for who and what we are. The police protect moreso than marginalize our communities and that was a long time in coming. Thank you for allowing All Persons Into OUR Parade. God Bless everyone. Philip Fernandes